CiteIt's Substack Demo

Share this post

How Substack Writers can Address the Crisis of Trust in Media

citeit22.substack.com

How Substack Writers can Address the
Crisis of Trust in Media

Featuring article and video by Matt Taibbi and Matt Orfalea

CiteIt > Demo > Substack Pitch

1) The Problem:

As "Mainstream Media" loses the trust of significant portions of the public, writers are seeking independence, publishing via new platforms like Substack or similar competitors. Once independent, writers face the challenge of earning the trust of additional subscribers beyond their core audience and pushing back against establishment gatekeepers who question writers' ability to operate independently, saying, for example, that writers like Matt Taibbi pretend that they’re being censored when in reality they just don’t want editors but they need them.

"Naked Quotations" Create Distrust

As an example, take a look at a controversial article Matt Taibbi wrote about the Nord Stream pipeline bombing containing what I call “ naked quotations” — quotations that are not clothed with any surrounding context.

These types of unsubstantiated or opaque quotations are rightly regarded with suspicion by non-aligned readers who have not yet subscribed, but solving this problem could buttress writers' and Substack's reputation and subscriber base. (Video)

2) Solution: live to a higher standard

CiteIt enables writers to distiguish themselves from the competition and push back against establishment critics by looking up and displaying the context of a citation when the writer specifies a source's url.

CiteIt could enable Substack writers to easily disclose the context of their html, pdf, audio, and video sources, providing Substack with a feature that differentiates it from its competitors and can be integrated across the Substack platform:
notes videos CiteIt could be added to Notes Videos
  1. post text
  2. post voiceovers
  3. audio
  4. video, and
  5. notes

3) How CiteIt Works:

The writer:

  1. links to their quotations's source url.

So The CiteIt webservice is able to:

  1. look up the context at the point when an article is published and then

  2. display this context to the reader.


4) Watch Demo: (A Writer’s view)

See a demonstration of the CiteIt WordPress plugin with a Ken Klippenstein article:  

Written Instructions
Documentation: how to use the WordPress plugin

  |   Examples Submitted

  username: public
  password: demo22

5) Proposed Next Steps:

  1. Proof of Concept:
    • Add Developer Code to page on Substack domain & Call CiteIt Web service
  2. Writers Test in Product lab, do more Usability Testing:
  3. Take Live for Everyone:
    • Improve scaleabily and robustness, work with dev/ops on deployment & possible javascript-based version of webservice.
      • Start with Writing: Posts & YouTube
      • Add Native Audio, Voiceovers
      • Add Native Video
      • Add PDF Support: digital, then OCR


Big-picture ideas:

  • A New Source of Revenue - Give readers the option to seamlessly purchase a full version of a cited works, beyond fair-use excerpts, expanding the market for the original creators' works.
  • "Substack Partners" would be implemented via an API that bills Substack readers for linked partner content available anywhere on the interent. All partner content providers have to do is register their work with Substact to opt in.
  • Trusted Content Business model of video/audio (countering AI deep-fakes)
© 2024 Tim Langeman      Home ∙ Demos ∙ Substack ∙ Try CiteIt! ∙ Code ∙ FAQ ∙ About

Success would look like a media environment where Substack has established a reputation for a higher standard of transparency and trust by:

  • better informing their readers,

  • earning the trust, of new readers that  

  • helping to differentiate Substack from platforms like Twitter and Threads,

  • defending reputations from gatekeepers and partisans.

If I aim higher, I will know we\u2019ve been maximally successful when I hear the concept of contextual citations discussed in general conversation:

  • associated with Substack, trust, innovation, and independent writers,

  • described as a solution to \u201Cnaked quotations\u201C

    , and

  • used as a critique of establishment media that does not provide contextual transparency.

4) Working with Substack

I anticipate that I would best be able to realize my vision for contextual citations by working with Substack.  CiteIt technology could be deployed first for long-form writing

, and later across the platform:

  • notes,

  • podcasts 

  • video

5) Watch Demo: (A Writer\u2019s view)

D) Next:
Watch Video: How to Create Contextual Citations using the WordPress Plugin

Documentation: how to use the WordPress plugin

   |   Written Instructions

\\n  username: public\\n  password: demo22\\n\\n
\",\"longer_truncated_body_json\":null,\"longer_truncated_body_html\":null,\"truncated_body_text\":\"A) Watch this Video first: \",\"wordcount\":609,\"postTags\":[],\"publishedBylines\":[{\"id\":159136973,\"name\":\"Tim Langeman\",\"handle\":null,\"previous_name\":null,\"photo_url\":\"https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/8bba56c5-8044-4f2d-b432-24b8408212a8_144x144.png\",\"bio\":\"Creator of CiteIt.net\",\"profile_set_up_at\":\"2023-07-25T18:36:58.778Z\",\"publicationUsers\":[{\"id\":1814751,\"user_id\":159136973,\"publication_id\":1829392,\"role\":\"admin\",\"public\":true,\"is_primary\":false,\"publication\":{\"id\":1829392,\"name\":\"Tim\u2019s Substack\",\"subdomain\":\"citeit22\",\"custom_domain\":null,\"custom_domain_optional\":false,\"hero_text\":\"My personal Substack\",\"logo_url\":\"https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/8bba56c5-8044-4f2d-b432-24b8408212a8_144x144.png\",\"author_id\":159136973,\"theme_var_background_pop\":\"#2096FF\",\"created_at\":\"2023-07-25T18:38:27.430Z\",\"rss_website_url\":null,\"email_from_name\":null,\"copyright\":\"Tim Langeman\",\"founding_plan_name\":null,\"community_enabled\":true,\"invite_only\":false,\"payments_state\":\"disabled\"}}],\"is_guest\":false,\"bestseller_tier\":null}],\"reaction\":false,\"reaction_count\":0,\"comment_count\":0,\"child_comment_count\":0,\"hasCashtag\":false,\"is_saved\":false,\"saved_at\":null,\"is_viewed\":false,\"restacked\":false},\"comments\":[],\"canonicalUrl\":\"/demo/substack//p/how-substack-writers-can-address\",\"inlineComments\":false,\"readerIsSearchCrawler\":false,\"ogUrl\":\"/demo/substack//p/how-substack-writers-can-address\",\"bannedFromNotes\":false,\"isChatActive\":false,\"isMeetingsActive\":false,\"iba\":false,\"features\":{},\"dd_env\":\"zuma-prod\",\"dd_ti\":true}")